Advantages of doing Wikipedia assignments rather than traditional term papers

The Wiki Education Foundation has just published a list of Five reasons a Wikipedia assignment is better than a term paper. The five reasons are:

 

  1. People read it
  2. Students have to think twice
  3. A term paper is rarely a force for good in the world
  4. Wikipedia has real and fascinating flaws
  5. The technology is just about the same

 

The text confirms some of the points we made in our Best Practice Guide to Use Wikipedia in University Education, by Maura Lerga and Eduard Aibar You can also read the Guide in Spanish and Catalan.

Advertisements

Thesis on Open Hardware in Hackerspaces successfully defended by Peter Dunajcsik (Maxigas)

Peter Dunajcsik (Maxigas), member of our research group, successfully defended his doctoral dissertation “Peer Production of Open Hardware: Unfinished Artefacts and Architectures in the Hackerspaces” at the Internet Interdisciplinary Institute (IN3 – UOC) on Wednesday 16 September 2015 with the best possible mark, summa cum laude. He gave an outstanding presentation and impressed the jury with his in-depth knowledge of the topic.

Dunajcsik’s supervisor for his PhD thesis was Eduard Aibar. The member of the examining committee were Johan Söderberg (University of Gothenburg), Nelly Oudshoorn (University of Twente) and Ramon Ribera (Universitat Oberta de Catalunya).

Maxigas Thesis Presentation

New OSI publication: “Wikipedia at university: What faculty think and do about it”

On 14th July, 2015, The Electronic Library has published our paper “Wikipedia at university: what faculty think and do about it”, with some results from the Wiki4HE project. In this article, we investigate university faculty perceptions and practices about Wikipedia.

The study was based on an extensive survey to all faculty members in two large public universities. A total of 913 valid responses were collected through an online questionnaire with nine control variables and 41 Likert-scaled questions. As main findings, the results do not support an overwhelming sceptical attitude among faculty towards Wikipedia. The quality of Wikipedia articles is highly valued and most faculty members are regular users, just as students are. Though most faculty show a positive view on the teaching usefulness of Wikipedia, few of them actually use it for teaching purposes. A certain conflict was detected between the standard academic procedures of knowledge building and the open collaborative model on which Wikipedia rests. In the end, two important factors play a role in shaping faculty views: (a) their colleagues’ perceived opinions and practices, and (b) academic disciplines.

More details:

Eduard Aibar, Josep Lladós-Masllorens, Antoni Meseguer-Artola, Julià Minguillón & Maura Lerga (2015, pre-print version). Wikipedia at university: what faculty think and do about it. The Electronic Library, Vol. 33. Iss. 4. Permanent link to this document: http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/EL-12-2013-0217

 

OSI participation in the ICWSM-15 workshop on Research into Wikipedia

Eduard Aibar took part in the 9th International Conference on Web and Social Media, ICWSM-15 (Oxford, UK, May 26-29, 2015). He attended the workshop Wikipedia, a Social Pedia: Research Challenges and Opportunities, with the paper “Wikipedia, Academia, and Science”.

Aibar’s paper presents some results of an ongoing OSI research project on the interactions between Wikipedia and Science, which analyses the scientific content of Wikipedia in order to explore how the non-expert nature of most of its editors and its open collaboration strategy shape the way science and technology issues are presented.

You can read the paper here.

The International AAAI Conference on Web and Social Media (ICWSM) is a forum for researchers in computer science and social science to come together to share knowledge, discuss ideas, exchange information, and learn about cutting-edge research in diverse fields with the common theme of online social media. ICWSM, now in its ninth year, has become one of the premier venues for computational social science.

A document with all the papers of the workshop is available here.

 

The Wiki4HE dataset is an open resource in the UCI Machine Learning Repository

The dataset we used in the Wiki4HE Project is been published in the UCI Machine Learning Repository , which is “a collection of databases, domain theories, and data generators that are used by the machine learning community for the empirical analysis of machine learning algorithms”, with more than 300 dataset available in its web page.
So, the dataset we used for our analysis on the teaching use of Wikipedia in higher education is now an open resource, freely available on line. The Wiki4HE dataset has 913 instances and 53 attributes. You can get all the information about the attributes description in the web. Feel free to download here (Data Folder and Data Set Description).

 

A-hierarchical open collaboration? How conflicts and bureaucratic rules make Wikipedia grow

Now available a video of the research seminar “A-hierarchical open collaboration? How conflicts and bureaucratic rules make Wikipedia grow”, by Prof. Dariusz Jemielniak (Kozminski University, Warsaw, Poland), organized by the OSI research group (IN3/UOC) last December, 9th 2014.

Abstract:

Wikipedia is often portrayed as an a-hierarchical, spontaneous, open-collaboration movement. These treats are definitely common for Wikipedia, yet it also does have a darker side. For a movement which despises hierarchies and structures, it is extremely over-regulated: the number of regulatory documents on English Wikipedia exceeds 400,000 words, and the bureaucratic creed is way out of control. Also, for a movement relying so much on collaboration, Wikipedia is a surprisingly solitary and conflict-driven community. In the presentation I am going to show how overregulation and conflicts actually help Wikipedia grow.